Claire L Cardwell

7 years ago · 3 min. reading time · ~100 ·

Claire L blog
Considering Buying/Renovating a Heritage Home? Pros and Cons by Claire Cardwell

Considering Buying/Renovating a Heritage Home? Pros and Cons by Claire Cardwell


Some people feel that Heritage-listed properties are fascinating windows into the past and that their owners are lucky.  Other people say that a Heritage listing is a real headache with development restrictions and price depreciation.

There are risks involved with buying a Heritage home, but in my opinion the benefits far out weigh the cons.

In South Africa , all structures over 60 years old - including fixtures and fittings - are protected by the National Heritage Resources Act, 25 of 1999.  All properties in a conservation or heritage area are also protected. Parts of Cape Town are listed as being of heritage value, like Wynberg Village, Observatory, Little Mowbray, St James and the City centre.

According to Graham Viney, award-winning designer, author and an expert when it comes to historic property in South Africa , the preservation of our country’s architectural treasures is frequently due to the collective clout of self-appointed local ‘watch dogs’, like those established in St James, Kalk Bay and Muizenberg.  

However, Viney points out that there are grey areas when it comes to ‘defining history’: ‘There are some who view so-called colonial architecture as testament to a repressive era and therefore unworthy of safeguarding. Really, though, these buildings are monuments to craftsmen who have gone before and should be treasured.’

“Whether bought fully-renovated or still in need of some love and care, the romance and emotional pull of an older home holds enormous appeal for many,” says Richard Day, Pam Golding Properties National General Manager. 

Pros : - 

0226aa51.jpg1.  Heritage properties frequentely attract higher resale values because they and often the surrounding areas are protected.  People may assume this means a property can’t be changed at all.  In fact work is encouraged to ensure a house is properly maintained and modernised;  you just need to know what aspects of the original building are especially important in maintaining its character.  

2. If you have a heritage home you may be able to apply for grants or loans to help fund it's upkeep or maintenence. For example the City of Johannesburg Department of Arts, Culture and Heritage, offers a 20% rebate for properties declared heritage sites. 

3.  It is unlikely that the area surrounding your house will be re-zoned or developed.

4.  If the property is well looked after it will retain it's appeal and will only grow in value with age.

Cons : -

1. There are more restrictions around the development of a heritage property, including how they can be renovated, the design and what building materials can be used.

9eb8eff2.jpg2. The cost of renovating a heritage property can also be higher.  In addition you will have to look out for surprise costs for remedial electrical work or replacing roof trusses etc.

3. Approvals for renovation or development will take longer.  Not only do you need to deal with your local council but heritage bodies will also need to approve your plans.  People wanting to buy and/or renovate a Heritage property should work with Heritage authorities and Council from the start.  

4. Complete demolition of a property isn’t usually allowed.

5. Home insurance may be harder to obtain so it's best to do some research before making an offer.

6. Heritage listed properties are old – make sure you organise thorough building and pest inspections.

Take a look at neighbouring properties to see if any of them have been renovated or extended.  If so your local Council/Heritage Authority is receptive and perhaps you will find good Contractors that are experienced in dealing with Heritage homes.

eb72d013.jpg“Many historic homes were built in prime central locations, or close to attractive natural features such as rivers and mountain backdrops. They may still occupy significantly larger erfs and have more and larger rooms than the average modern home. They also tend to be well-built structures, with thick walls, wooden floors and old-school attention to detail and craftsmanship,” says Richard Day.

“It is often such features, and if they form part of a well-maintained, fully-renovated historic property, which may command a premium price, more than any intrinsic heritage value or significance.”

Day says an ill-maintained historic property, or one requiring insensitive renovations, will often fetch a lower price than an equivalent modern home, given the cost of restoring it to its former glory.  “Buyers who dream of renovating old homes should also be aware that they cannot just move in and start building,” says Day.

“Before taking on an historical property, make sure that it is generally suitable for your requirements in terms of size and plan. Sometimes people buy buildings because of their historical charm, only to completely alter them or to remove all patina or sense of past history,” says Day.

“Find a house you like, and consider its pros and cons objectively, as well as emotionally. The more logically you approach buying the house, the more you're going to love living in it.”


I love Architecture. I think it's vital to talk about all aspects of Architecture - whether it be planning, construction, design or green building. I have written 3 E-Books & over 110 articles. Please feel free to let me know if you have any queries regarding architecture, planning & construction & I will assist you.

I am originally from the UK and moved to South Africa
in 1999.  I started Blue Designs in 2004 after working as a driver for Avalon Construction on a luxury home in the Featherbrook Estate.  In my spare time I am an artist and writer.

+27 11 025 4458

Other articles I have written include :-

Follow me on beBee -

I've started two new Hives - please feel free to join!

Useful Links : -

Sources : -


Articles from Claire L Cardwell

View blog
5 years ago · 7 min. reading time

I remember my trip to the Leaning Tower of Pisa - I must have been about 3 or 4 and when my legs got ...

5 years ago · 4 min. reading time

The Story of House Chidi, was a long one, in fact both my Client and I will both agree, it was hard ...

4 years ago · 3 min. reading time

In the Zhejiang countryside the Shanhai based design studio Wutopia Lab installed the Shrine of What ...

You may be interested in these jobs

  • Afrizan People Intelligence

    Rail Coordinator

    Found in: Emprego ZA C2 - 3 days ago

    Afrizan People Intelligence Sasolburg, South Africa

    Rail Logistics: · Continuous monitoring and expediting of railway wagons to ensure timely delivery of raw materials to different sites around the country and including Sasolburg. · Daily communication ...

  • Sheli Placements

    Half Day Bookkeeper

    Found in: Emprego ZA C2 - 3 days ago

    Sheli Placements Norwood, South Africa

    An organisation based in Waverley Jhb is looking for an experienced HALF DAY BOOKKEEPER. · Must have PASTEL PARTNER and SAGE PAYROLL · Must be a very precise and accurate individual · Must be able to ...

  • Isilumko Staffing (JHB)

    IT Service Delivery

    Found in: Executive Placements ZA C2 - 1 week ago

    Isilumko Staffing (JHB) Cape Town, South Africa

    Our BPO client is looking for Service Delivery candidates: · Basic Function: This is a business and client facing role that ensures a seamless IT Service Management, helping business growth and creat ...